| 2012 Member | # | Best 15 | Phase I | Best 5 | Phase II | Best 5 | Phase III | Best 5 | |||
| George Faro | 15 | 149.0 | Peter Haupt | 55.5 | Mitch Bisgeier | 59.0 | Brandon Macy | 55.5 | |||
| Marty Cutler | 15 | 148.0 | Alex Garcia | 52.0 | Marty Cutler | 55.5 | George Faro | 53.5 | |||
| Alex Garcia | 15 | 146.5 | Sam DeLuca | 50.5 | Greg Roth | 54.5 | Alex Garcia | 49.0 | |||
| Brandon Macy | 15 | 141.0 | Marty Cutler | 50.0 | Pat Lynch | 52.0 | Peter Haupt | 49.0 | |||
| Peter Haupt | 15 | 140.5 | |||||||||
| Rob Peason | 49.0 | Peter Kenny | 50.5 | Mitch Bisgeier | 45.5 | ||||||
| Peter Kenny | 15 | 139.5 | Dee Musto | 47.0 | George Faro | 48.0 | Greg Roth | 44.5 | |||
| Pat Lynch | 15 | 139.0 | Peter Kenny | 46.5 | Alex Garcia | 45.5 | Pat Lynch | 43.0 | |||
| Greg Roth | 15 | 136.0 | Brandon Macy | 46.0 | Rob Peason | 38.0 | Peter Kenny | 41.0 | |||
| Mitch Bisgeier | 15 | 129.5 | Carl Schoenberger | 45.5 | Carl Schoenberger | 36.5 | Marty Cutler | 39.0 | |||
| Rob Peason | 15 | 127.0 | Pat Lynch | 43.5 | Jeff Smith | 36.5 | Rob Peason | 38.0 | |||
| Sam DeLuca | 15 | 122.5 | George Faro | 42.5 | Sam DeLuca | 35.5 | Carl Schoenberger | 36.0 | |||
| Carl Schoenberger | 15 | 118.0 | Jeff Smith | 36.0 | Brandon Macy | 35.0 | Sam DeLuca | 32.0 | |||
| Dee Musto | 14 | 99.0 | Greg Roth | 34.0 | Steve Reichman | 33.5 | Dee Musto | 32.0 | |||
| Steve Reichman | 15 | 93.0 | Steve Reichman | 30.0 | Peter Haupt | 33.0 | Steve Reichman | 24.0 | |||
| Jeff Smith | 15 | 88.5 | Mitch Bisgeier | 20.0 | Dee Musto | 12.0 | Jeff Smith | 12.5 | |||